Skip to content

Hospice Movement has something to say about public executions

Hospice Movement has something to say about public executions

By: Craig Dresang, CEO, YoloCares

 

If Swiss psychiatrist Elisabeth Kubler-Ross, author of the landmark book On Death and Dying, were alive today she would likely have something to say about America’s current flirtation with the idea of public executions.  

 

Her work gives us reason to question the spectacle of an open air killing. For Kubler-Ross and for the families of the executed, such an event would be met with profound grief, distress, and powerful ethical opposition. As a pioneer in thanatology (the study of death and dying) and the psychiatrist who introduced the Five Stages of Grief, her entire life’s work was dedicated to bringing decency, empathy, grace, and calm to the dying process . . .    regardless of circumstance.

 

Like Kubler-Ross, Dame Cicely Saunders, the founder of the modern hospice movement, believed death should be a time of reconciliation, mercy, and decorum. Both women understood that killing, or responding to death with more death, does not heal the living. Turning capital punishment into a pageant for the masses is a cruel and unnecessary disregard for the innocent families of the executed . . .   creating life-altering psychological and spiritual injury.  This sort of capital punishment represents a societal choice to meet violence with violence, which ultimately fails to resolve the underlying trauma or grief experienced by the victims’ families.

 

Yet, if US Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth has his way, the public will be able to watch the execution of a former US Army major by firing squad. The Pentagon has announced plans to livestream the execution of Nidal Hasan, who killed 12 US soldiers and one civilian at the Fort Hood military base in 2009.  The proposed broadcast would turn an execution into theatre.  The cost of admission is an internet connection.  Unprecedented in the modern era of American history.

 

The justification to proceed with both capital punishment and public executions has been framed as a warning and often wrapped in religious rhetoric.  Hegseth recently said, “People need to understand that there’s serious consequences for these types of things.”  However, most religious traditions raise legitimate questions and concerns about man’s thirst for revenge.

 

Jesus of Nazareth, himself subjected to public execution, challenged “eye for an eye” justice.  In the Gospel of John, he confronts those seeking to stone a woman accused of adultery.  He effectively stopped her public execution by daring the executioners, “Let anyone of you who is without sin be the first to throw a stone.”  It was a direct challenge to retributive capital justice in a time and place where public executions were common tools of state terror.  Today, more than 2.3 billion people worship this man who was executed by the state. One could argue that the decision to humiliate him, intimidate his followers, and demonstrate the power of authority, backfired in a splendid way.

 

Other religious traditions also offer resources for questioning vengeance. The teachings of the Prophet Muhammad, uphold a core philosophy that divine law governs life and death; deterrence is necessary, but human mercy and forgiveness are always superior.  The Buddha, too, promoted a philosophy of absolute non-violence, believing that cosmic karma eliminates the need for human vengeance.  Clearly, appeals to mercy and nonviolence deserve a place in this debate.

 

The Pentagon’s plan to livestream an execution is raising ethical questions about capital punishment.  But the deeper question is this: Who are we as a people?

 

Executing a perpetrator presents a false promise of closure, but the hospice tradition challenges the idea that another death will bring anything of value.  Grief does not follow a required sequence, and victims’ families will not all find healing in the same way.  

 

Kübler-Ross advocated for facing death with dignity and achieving a sense of peace or acceptance. Capital punishment forces a highly clinical, scheduled, and adversarial death, which strips away the opportunity for natural spiritual growth, reconciliation, or genuine repentance before the end of life. Central to her later work was the belief that the ultimate purpose of life is to learn unconditional love. She famously stated that there is no sin that cannot be forgiven and that every human being, regardless of their actions, possesses a spark of the divine. She would view the institutionalized killing of a human being as a failure of societal compassion and an act rooted in collective fear and anger rather than love.

 

The compassion at the heart of this work does not require us to excuse a murderer’s actions.  It asks whether we can condemn an atrocity without surrendering our commitment to human dignity.  

 

Viewed through the values these women championed, a public execution stands in stark opposition to humane end-of-life practices and philosophy.  Their work reminds us that human dignity always matters, especially during someone’s final days.  That principle becomes harder – and more important – to defend when the person dying has caused terrible harm.  We owe the victims and their families remembrance, support, and justice. Turning a death into a public spectacle will never fulfill that obligation.  

 

 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *